How to Configure Multi-Track Remote Recording with Multiple “Mix-Minus” using Logic Pro on macOS

Ever wanted to record individual podcast guests over a remote recording (e.g. using Zoom, Skype out, etc.) without losing the option to record them into individual tracks?

If you tried you’ll know that the hard part is to configure the infamous “Mix Minus”. Mix-Minus is that option that allows everyone on the group call to hear each other but not themselves. In order to do this, you need to feed each of the participants a mix of the group call minus their own channel, hens the term “mix-minus“.

This article is specific to Logic Pro X, from Apple and for Apple’s macOS. Similar steps can be used for other tools, and other tools can be found for the MS Windows operating system, but are beyond the scope of this article.

Follow these steps to configure your macOS to record a live podcast with multiple remote co-hosts using Logic Pro.

Pre-requisites

  • Latest MacOS with up-to-date Logic Pro X installed
  • Loopback by Rogue Amoeba

The Theory on One Leg

In order to record multiple remote users we need to solve two separate challenges:

1. Route each co-host’s source into a separate track in Logic Pro

2. Send back an individual mixdown to each participant, known as a “mix-minus”, so they can hear each other.

In order to send and receive individual input/output for each source, we will use the Loopback application to create multiple “Virtual Audio Devices”.

To understand what is a virtual audio device, let’s see how a physical audio device looks on our computer.

When you plug a USB audio device such as a microphone or USB mixer into your computer, it shows up as a physical audio device. Once it is detected by your computer, you can choose it as a source for an audio program like Skype, Zoom, Google Hangout or Logic Pro to name a few.

A virtual device can turn a software-based audio application, such as iTunes, YouTube player running inside a browser, or the output of any communication software such as Skype, Zoom or FaceTime, into a virtual device, just as if it was a physical USB microphone.

The first challenge is that Logic Pro X, which is a Digital Audio Workstation (DAW) program, is that it can only configure a single device as its source for recording. This means we can only record the channels that this single device is exposing, so either the USB mic, or a Zoom session, or a Skype session but not all at once.

But in our case, we want to record multiple different sources, at once. E.g. we want to use our own USB microphone, the output of Skype for one of your co-hosts, the output of FaceTime for another co-host, etc.

The next challenge is that in order to have a conversation with your co-hosts, they all need to hear you and each other as well as any audio you might be playing locally like sound-effects from a soundboard or some music you are playing through iTunes, and, as a reminder, you want all these to be recorded individually into separate tracks so that you can edit them individually later on.

The easiest way to do this is by sending the final mix of all these tracks back to all the participants. But if you’ll do this, a few things might happen:

1. There might be feedback/echo if their voice is bleeding back into their microphone

2. They will hear themselves with a slight delay (50 to 500 milliseconds, depending on the Internet speed and physical distance) which is just long enough to make their brain go crazy, playing an evil torture game with their sanity.

The solution to this problem is called a “Mix-Minus”. This is a mix of all the audio sources “minus” their own voice. This way they can hear everyone else, but there is no issue of hearing themselves in a delay or a chance of their own voice bleeding back into their microphone to cause any feedback.

For some reason, a Mix-Minus is one of the hardest things to understand as well as configure. And the more participants and audio sources you have, the more complex the solution becomes.

As I mentioned before, these two problems of recording each audio source into its own track, and creating the individual mix-minus for each participant, are two separate problems, but they are interwound.

In order to make it easier to follow and configure, I will first focus on the recording part, and then on the mix-minus part.

Configuring remote multi-track recording

In this part we will do the following:

1. Using Loopback, we will create a “virtual device” for each software-based audio source (such as a music player like iTunes, a communication software like Skype, a sound effects soundboard, etc.)

2. We will create a special “Virtual Device” on the OS level, called an “Aggregate Device” to combine all these separate inputs into channels of a single device

3. In Logic Pro we will use this new “Aggregate Device” as the audio input (and output) for our session

4. We will configure the various inputs inside Logic Pro and do a test recording to see that each source is really mapped to its own track

Before we begin, I want you to take a moment and list all the input sources you are going to use, and for each write down if it is a physical or digital source.

In addition, for each digital device mark if it supports selecting an input source (like Skype, or FaceTime) or not (like iTunes, VLC, etc.)

E.g. a typical list might look like this:

NamePhysical/DigitalSelectable Input
USB MicPhysicaln/a
SoundboardPhysicaln/a
SkypeDigitalYes
ZoomDigitalyes
FaceTimeDigitalyes
iTunesDigitalno

Physical devices are already showing in your computer as inputs that you can choose when configuring tools like Logic Pro.

But, there is no way to choose a software source such as Skype, Zoom, FaceTime, iTunes, etc without some trickery.

This is where Loopback comes to the rescue. Loopback can create as many virtual audio devices as you might need.

Launch Loopback, and repeat the following for the Digital sources (no need to do it for the physical ones):

  • Click the “(+) New Virtual Device” button in the lower-left side of the window
  • Name it by the name of the device followed by “Output”, e.g. “Skype Output” or “iTunes Output” (this will help us identify them later on)
  • Leave all the other settings as is (Mute Audio source: “on”, Channel Mapping: “Automatic” and no audio sources)
  • If the source has no selectable input, click the ‘+’ button of the Audio Sources list at the top and look for that software in the list (e.g. look for iTunes, or Safari or Chrome)

As soon as you make the changes, your computer will add these new “Output” devices to the list of devices you can select as inputs. See the two examples below of the iTunes and FaceTime virtual Outputs.

As you can see in these two examples we left the “Audio Source” empty for the “FaceTime Output” (because we can choose the output device when we use FaceTime) and we set the iTunes “Audio Source” to iTunes (because there is no way to change the output of iTunes from the app).

Next, we need to overcome the limitation that you can only define one input device Logic Pro.

In order to do this, we need to use a special MacOS built-in utility called “Audio Midi Setup”. Despite the name, this tool does more than setting up Midi. The easiest way to find this tool is to use Spotlight and type “Audio Midi Setup”. Otherwise, you can open Finder, click on the Go menu and choose Utilities, or hit CMD+SHIFT+U. This will open the “Utilities” folder on your mac, and in it, you will find the “Audio Midi Setup” program.

Launch it, and in it, you will create a single Virtual Device but this time in the OS level, that combines all the devices (physical and virtual) into a single “Aggregate Device” that we can then use with Logic as our single input device. Don’t confuse the term Virtual Device here with the term Virtual Device in Loopback. This one is slightly different and is not controlled by Loopback.

To create the Aggregate Device, in the lower-left corner of the “Audio Midi Setup tool” click the ‘+’ button and choose “Create Aggregate Device”

You may rename it to something that easier to find like “Podcasting Aggregate Device” by clicking its name in the left side-bar and typing the new name:

Now we are ready to add all the new virtual and physical devices we want to include in this aggregate device.

Let’s start with the standard system output so that we can have access to the speakers/headphones of the device (otherwise we will not be able to hear anything we do). Next check all the devices you want to use in your setup including the physical devices like your USB microphones and/or USB adapters/mixers, as well as the virtual Outputs we have created before for each of the applications we want to use like iTunes, Skype, FaceTime, etc.

Notice what we got here:

The input channels show 4 pairs of inputs and the output channels shows 4 pairs of outputs.

These numbers (1 through 8) will later show in Logic X as our selectable inputs for each track so leave this window open for quick reference of which numbers go with which source.

Launch Logic Pro, open the “Preferences-> Audio” settings and select our new “Podcasting Aggregate Device” as the input/output device:

The last thing we need to do is create a track for each of our sources, choose the relevant input for each and label them.

Tip: when you add tracks (using the plus ‘+’ button at the top left corner of the timeline editor) you want to use the “(1+2)” style for stereo tracks and the single-digit numbers for mono tracks. Also, make sure you choose “Audio” as the type of source and not Instruments, etc.

Before we can record these sources, you’ll need to go to each of the applications (Skype, Zoom, FaceTime, etc.) and configured their audio setting to use the relevant “Output” device as their “Speaker/Output” E.g. In Skype go to the audio settings and choose the “Skype Output” device as the output device. Do the same for each software you want to use for your participants (the ones that you marked as having a “selectable input” in the table above.)

That’s it. Now just arm all these tracks in Logic Pro for recording (click the ‘R’ button) and the Input monitor (‘I’ button) for each of these, and start recording, while ensuring that Logic is capturing the audio of each of these sources into their own audio track.

Next, we will set up the mix-minus configuration for each of the participants so that they can hear what you can hear, or very close to it.

Configuring a Mix-Minus submix for Each Participant

As we mentioned, each participant wants to hear the voice of all the other participants except for their own, to reduce feedback and due to the long Internet delays.

Here is a quick summary of the steps we are about to take:

• In Loopback, we will create an additional virtual device for each “mix-minus” we need (one per target like Skype, FaceTime, Zoom, etc.)

• In the “Audio Midi Setup” tool, add these new virtual “mix-minus” devices to our “Podcasting Aggregate Device” (so that we can access them from Logic)

• Back in Logic, create individual mixes for each participant using the “send” feature and route it back to their individual mix-minus virtual device

• In the relevant applications, choose the new mix-minus we created as the “input”

So, let’s start by creating a new Virtual Device in Loopback for each application we want to use for communicating with a co-host/guest speaker (e.g. “Skype Mix-Minus”, “FaceTime Mix-Minus”, Zoom Mix-Minus” etc.

Note that we only need these for applications that represent remote speakers. You don’t need to create these for applications like iTunes, VLC, etc. Also due to the default behavior of these tools, by default, you can only have one person for each tool. You can find some methods on the internet for how to run multiple copies of some of these tools simultaneously, but it is beyond the scope of this post. For this post, we assume you use one software per guest (e.g. guest one on Skype, guest two on FaceTime, guest three on Zoom and guest 4 on Google Hangout)

Note: you may or may not have a default “pass-through” device, but in any case, you may ignore it.

All these devices we just created are what is called by Loopback a “pass-through” device. All it means is that it creates a virtual device that is not dedicated to any specific software, and it allows to connect to it any input/output of any software on the computer.

We will now go to each of these applications (Skype, FaceTime, etc.) and configured their input to be these individual Mix-Minus devices (e.g. “Skype Mix-Minus”, “Facetime Mix-Minus” etc.) so that once the session is live, our Logic Pro mix-minus will feed into them the specific mix instead of them picking our microphone or something else.

Next, open the “Audio Midi Setup” tool again, and in our “Podcasting Aggregate Device” select the checkbox of these newly created Mix-Minus virtual devices:

In this example, we added Skype and Facetime and you can see the additional 9-12 channels that were added to our list.

Yet again, take a note of which numbers belong to which mix-minus virtual device (in the example above 9-10 is mapped to Skype and 11-12 is mapped to Facetime).

Wait: before we can continue, we need to force Logic to refresh its list of channels from the updated “Podcasting Aggregate Device” due to a bug in the current version. A quick way to do this is to reselect the input/output in the Logic Prefences->Audio dialog. Just select another one and then back to the “Podcasting Aggregate Device”, or otherwise you can quit and relaunch Logic.

Now comes the last step, which is probably the most confusing of them all, creating the actual mix-minus for each in Logic Pro.

What are we about to do next?

For each remote participant program, we will create a “private dedicated mix” inside Logic that is fed with all the inputs we want except for their own output.

In order to do this, we will use the “send” feature in Logic. Send is typically used in audio mixing to send a “copy” of the audio of a track to a different target, such as an effect rack, without affecting the original track itself.

We will use this method to send each user a copy of all the other sources except their own (mix-minus) as follows:

We will first create an “aux” channel for each mix-minus we need and set its input to a unique “bus number” in Logic so that we can send audio to each of these. If you are not familiar with busses, think of them as physical wires that allow you to route audio from one place to another. You can send multiple sources into the same bus, and then send this bus to any number of inputs.

In our case, we will create a bus for each mix-minus, and then we will create an aux track (track that is only for adjustments but can’t be armed and recorded) that will map this bus to the relevant output (no the stereo one) to be sent back to the application that consumes this mix-minus.

In the mixer window, click the “Options” button and select “Create New Auxiliary Channel Strip”

Name it after the mix-minus you are about to use it for (e.g. Skype Mix-Minus) and in the output change it from “Stereo Out” to the relevant number for this mix-minus in the Midi Setup output channels list.

In addition, set the input to a free bus number. I’m going to use bus numbers 10+ for the mix-minus audio. I’ll use bus 10 for Skype and bus 11 for FaceTime.

Once you are done it should look something like this (We added one for Skype and one for FaceTime):

Note that Logic also created additional output master tracks (purple) for us for each of these tracks.

Finally, we are now in the last part of the process:

For each mix-minus, we need to send to its bus the input of all the other sources except for its own.

E.g. for the Skype setup we will send the Mic, FaceTime, and iTunes but not Skype:

We will start with the Mic track: hit the “send” button on the Mic track, and send it to “bus 10 Skype Mix-Minus”

Next, click the narrow gray button under the send we just created, to add another send, and repeat the above but this time send it to “bus 11 – FaceTime mix-minus”

With that our mic is being sent to both mix-minus of Skype and Facetime.

Make sure to set the send level to 0db (otherwise nothing will be sent) by turning the know next to the send button to 0 (you may option-click it to set it to zero quickly).

Next, in the Skype-track create a single send to the FaceTime bus 11.

In the FaceTime-track create a single send and send it only to bus 10, “Skype”.

Finally, in the iTunes track, create two send buttons and send them to both Skype and Facetime (just like with the mic) because we want both participants to be able to hear the music played on iTunes.

Don’t forget to set the send volume to 0dB on all these newly created sends.

Your final screen should look like this:

You may want to rename the purple “Output 9-10” to “Skype Mix Output” and “Output 11-12” to “FaceTime mix output”

Also, do not forget to set the volume of the two aux (yellow) channels to 0db.

That’s it, you are all set.

To control the overall volume you send each participant, adjust the volume of their respective mix-minus channel.

If they ask you to increase the volume of a specific input (say the iTunes input or your mic) simple adjust the send amount using the small knobs next to the relevant send button.

You are all set. Run a test recording with all your guests connected and see that they can all hear each other.

You may want to save this as a template for future recording sessions.

My 5 minutes Tahini Recipe

Ingredients

  • 1 x cup Tahini
  • 1 x cup extra cold water
  • Salt
  • Citric Acid (optional)
  • Cumin
  • 1/2 cup of Lemon&Garlic juice (see instructions in my Hummus Recipe)
  • Optional: Parsley (for green style tahini)

Preparation

We will make the Tahini directly in the container we will store it in using a handheld stick blenders, so pick a container that is tall enough to hold the Tahini and to be used for the blending process

Image result for hand held stick blender
Example stick blender

Put all the ingredients into the container:

  • 1 cup Tahini paste
  • 1 cup of extra cold water
  • ½ tbsp salt
  • ¼ teaspoon citric acid (optional)
  • ¼ teaspoon cumin
  • The Lemon & Garlic juice.
  • Tip: For more of a “green Tahini” style, add about a handful of parsley leaves into the container.

Blend and mesh with the stick blender for a few minutes, taste and add spices as needed.

If the consistency is not liquid enough add a small amount of cold water and keep running. The texture should be smooth silky and the consistency should be semi-liquid like that of a pancake’s batter.

Enjoy with some Hummus!

My Homemade Hummus Recipe

TL;DR? jump to recipe

Growing up in Israel, I learned to appreciate great Hummus. No, not that Hummus as a side or as a dip, Hummus as the main dish, the hero of your lunch or dinner!

Hummus as the Hero
People standing in line for Ali Karavan's Hummus
They stand in line for Ali Karavan (Abu Hassan) Hummus in old town Jaffa

I’m talking about the Hummus that people stand in line for, like Abu Hassan (aka Ali Karavan) in old town Jaffa, and many others in other parts of the country like Acco and Haifa.

Over the 14+ years of living in the USA, I kept looking for the perfect Hummus dish, and with the exception of few rare places that are not in my area or even state, I found nothing.

So about 7 years ago I started the journey of mastering the perfect plate of homemade Hummus.

I have tried so many recipes, so many ideas, and so many ingredients, and only in the last year or so, I found my “hero” recipe.

Here is what I learned:

  • The most important for the taste is the Tahini.
  • 2nd most important is using fresh lemon juice, and a lot of it
  • Beans should be good and thick, but I found that beans from a can are the fastest and most consistent way to get from craving Hummus to eating it.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m still in love with the Abu-Hassan hummus and especially Messabacha dish. I don’t claim to be close to risk his throne, but what I achieved here allows me to have a hummus lunch or dinner a few times a week at home without feeling sad! (Let’s face it, I eat hummus every day, just like the stereotypical Israeli guy!)

So here it is, I give you my Israeli-style Hummus Recipe, the one that is as close as I could get to my beloved Hummus back in Israel.

Raz’s Hummus Recipe

Prep time: ~60 minutes

Serving Size: ~2.5 Lbs

Ingredients

  • 2 x Cans SAHADI Chickpeas (buy) read at the end to learn why I use canned beans.
  • 1 x Cup Al Wadi Tahina Paste (buy)
  • ½ x Cup Extra light Olive Oil (buy)
  • 1 x Cup Extra Cold Water
  • Salt (~1 teaspoon)
  • Cumin (pinch)
  • 3-4 x Garlic Cloves
  • 3-4 x Lemons
  • Baking Soda

Preparation

  1. Rinse Chickpeas
    Wash well from any of the can’s liquid residue (unlike common belief, the cooking water is not great for Hummus. Freshwater does a much better work).
  2. Place in a pot cover with freshwater about 1.5-2 inches above the level of the beans (make sure the beans are never exposed, always ensure there is water over them).
  3. Add ½ teaspoon of baking soda
  4. Heat/cook Chickpeas for ~15 minutes at maximum heat. Keep pot half-covered and watch for foam overflow(!!!). Stir every few minutes and scoop foam and any detached shells during the cooking process (baking soda is helping to separate the shells and soften the beans).
  5. Rinse and wash beans thoroughly in cold water and separate as many of the shells as you can.
    Tip: run the beans in between your palms to separate as many of the shells from the beans and throw the shells away. To get rid of the shells, fill the container with water so they float and slowly tilt the container so that the shells that are floating will fall out with the water as you drain it slowly.
  6. Place the beans in a bowl covered with fresh cold water and place to cool down in the fridge for ~10-15 minutes (this colling ensures the cooking process is stopped and helps to work with the beans in the grinding step).

Lemon Juice with Garlic

While the beans are cooking and/or cooling prepare the lemon juice with garlic as follow:

  • Squeeze the juice of 3-4 fresh lemons (about 1/2 – 3/4 of a cup)
  • take 4-5 garlic cloves and separate them from most of their shell (not too critical because of the way we will crush them)
  • Place the fresh lemon juice and the garlic cloves into a mini food processor with a splash of fresh water (less than 1/8th of a cup at most)
  • Smash it all together in the mini food processor
  • Using a fine-mesh strainer, pure the mix into a container, and use a spoon to smash the garlic through the strainer
fine mesh strainer
  • Once all the lemon and smashed garlic passed through the strainer put it aside until the next step.

This will give you a lemon juice that is mixed with garlic, without having these chunks of garlic in your hummus.

Once the beans have cooled down and the lemon/garlic juice is ready, we can move on to the final step.

  • Rinse the beans one last time, getting rid of any leftover floating shells. Drain the beans to get rid of all left water.
  • For the mixing phase use a food processor with a lower metal blade, like this one
Image result for food processor blades
  • Fill the food processor’s container with:
    • The beans (you may keep a small amount for decoration if you want)
    • 1 cup tahini paste (stir well first)
    • ½ tbsp salt
    • ¼ teaspoon cumin
    • The Garlic+lemon juice
  • Start the food processor. Watch the texture of the hummus as it is being processed. Slowly add the cold water as needed to achieve the desired consistency. A good Israeli style hummus is silky smooth yet firm enough so that when the blade is taken out, the hummus stands still in the container. Stop and taste. You can add more of the spices as you see fit.
  • Once you are happy with the taste, keep running for 2-3 minutes
  • While running, slowly add the ½ cup of extra light olive oil.
  • Stop the food processor and check the consistency of the Hummus. Again if you brought it to the right level, once the blade is taken out, the Hummus should stand still like this:

Serving Tips

Serve the Hummus with light paprika, pine nuts, good (not light) virgin olive oil and some parsley.

Typically served together with Tahini on top (recipe here). Usually, you eat with your hands using a fresh pita (this is my wife’s pita).

Brave people will eat it with a strong and spicy Yeman dip called S’CHUG (a recipe I found online)

A lite option can be eating it with Moon Pops.

Why I use beans from a can?

Many people will only use dry garbanzo beans and go through the process of soaking and cooking for hours. Personally, I yet to find a winning cooking method that gave me the expected consistency, and the canned beans give me great results and save me 2-3 hours of cooking and 12 hours of prep (soaking, switching water, etc.), so I use canned beans! Sorry!